Targeting BAPS over alleged labor law violation by contractor shows rising Hinduphobia in USA

In yet another case of anti-Hindu sentiment in the West, the Bochasanwasi Shri Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha (BAPS) Hindu sect has been targeted by US media and their lackeys in Bharat’s media.

BAPS is a socio-spiritual Hindu organization with its roots in the Vedas which describes itself as a ‘volunteer-driven organization dedicated to improving society through individual growth by fostering the Hindu ideals of faith, unity, and selfless service.’

BAPS has constructed Swaminarayan temples all across the world and one of the largest temples in the US is being constructed at Robbinsville, New Jersey, USA which has a 400,000 strong Hindu community. Inaugurated in 2014, some parts of the temple are still being constructed.

On April 30, it was reported that the New Jersey Department of Labour (NJDOL) issued an order against construction contractor Cunha’s Construction Inc for repeat violations that include misclassifying workers. As per the report on this NJDOL order, “The NJDOL’s Division of Wage and Hour Compliance conducted site visits at two of the company’s current worksites, BAPS Temple in Robbinsville and BAPS Temple in Edison, after learning of the projects from workers. These inspections found the contractor was paying workers in cash off the books and did not have workers’ compensation insurance.” The order issued by NJDOL is against the American construction contractor company owned by one Nuno Cunha and not against BAPS which has merely hired the services of the construction contractor.

Following this order, FBI and US Department of Homeland Security agents descended on 11 May at the Robbinsville temple to probe the violations. There was also mention of a lawsuit being filed by some Bharatiya workers/ex-workers who had worked at the temple site.

However, the media coverage of this matter went overboard in targeting BAPS with frenzied articles aimed at blemishing the reputation of the organization.

  • For example, this story in American Bazaar mentions an FBI raid on the Robbinsville temple but fails to mention that BAPS had outsourced their construction work to Cunha’s Construction Inc. Instead, the story has unnecessarily included a completely irrelevant angle of the workers being Dalits.
  • Not surprisingly New York Times, known for targeting the Modi government, published a story with the headline, ‘Hindu Sect Is Accused of Using Forced Labor to Build N.J. Temple.’ The story does not even try to disguise its intent to malign the Hindu community. According to this NYT story, lawyers who filed on behalf of the workers said that “…BAPS that has close ties to India’s ruling party and has built temples around the world, had exploited possibly hundreds of low-caste men in the years long construction project.” This is clear targeting of a Hindu organization.
  • As mentioned in an article in The Organiser, the violation of labour laws by Cunha’s Construction Inc was used to project Hindus as ‘casteist’ with known Hinduphobe Audrey Truschke jumping into the fray with a series of tweets on caste discrimination and Equality Labs attempting the same. In the past, Equality Labs has been known for it attempts to deliberately malign Bharat and Hindu Dharma.
  • Known Hindu-baiting propaganda site, The Wire covered the issue using the headline ‘Dalit Workers Allege ‘Shocking Violations’ in Building Temple in New Jersey’ although there is no concrete evidence on there being a Dalit angle at all.
  • Others who covered the story with the same anti-Hindu bias include Shekhar Gupta’s The Print (here) and The Times of India (here) which used the headline ‘Largest temple in US being built using forced labour?

To use labour violations by an American-owned labour contracting service as a means to whip up a frenzy against Hindus and to drag ‘casteism’ into any and every issue related to Hindus is a clear sign of the prevailing Hinduphobia of these media outlets. The entry of anti-Hindu activist orgs like Equality Labs and academics like Audrey Truschke to comment on the issue indicates that this has been a concerted exercise to attack Hindus and their sects.

Is it a coincidence that Hinduphobia has become more marked in the US after Biden became POTUS? Evidence suggests that anti-Hindu forces have gained traction in the Biden regime such as with the hiring of an anti-Hindu, anti-Modi diplomat as CIA  chief or a Kashmir-extremist supporter as Biden’s economic policy advisor. The blocking of vaccine raw material exports to Bharat while the country is struggling with the Covid second wave, despite US not needing those raw materials for its own vaccine production, has led to murmurs of a soft regime-change operation being put into motion.

Anti-Hindu hatred had been witnessed during the Obama regime when several episodes of Hindu temple desecration were reported from around the country. For example, there were 17 instances of vandalism reported between July and October 2014 in Virginia, incidents in February 2015 in Washington state, and incidents in Texas in April 2015. A Swaminarayan temple had been vandalized in the state of Kentucky in January 2019.

Regarding the targeting of BAPS, a twitter handle called Hindusamata pointed out that alleging that BAPS is ‘casteist’ is untrue since most devotees who visit BAPS temples are Patels who are not considered ‘upper caste’, and in any case Hindu Dharma does not endorse casteism.

If labourers have been exploited and labour laws violated as alleged, then workers must receive justice. However, the whole exercise seems to have focused on Hindu bashing rather than giving justice to the labourers who have allegedly been exploited. This becomes even more obvious when one finds that many of these reports which describe the case have unnecessarily dragged in caste and ‘Dalits’ without providing concrete numbers and have also dragged in BAPS’ alleged closeness to the Modi government when the issue is completely irrelevant in the case.

Significantly, most of the reports have left out the good work done by BAPS in USA and Bharat.

Fortunately, one report which detailed the whole case at length also spoke about the good work done by BAPS:

“Along with the temples, BAPS is involved in community and charity work. During the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S., the organization donated food and masks to hospitals across the country. Currently, as India is grappling with a devastating second surge of the coronavirus outbreak, BAPS Charities, through its network of partner hospitals in India and newly created temporary medical facilities, is working to accommodate the surge of patients unable to receive medical care by providing ventilators, oxygen supplies, concentrators, medicines, medical therapies, and other diagnostic services. They are also providing PPE and other necessary supplies to healthcare providers and those displaced by the pandemic. In addition to the physical support,  volunteers  are supporting the silent victims of the pandemic, the families of the afflicted, by providing hot meals and more importantly comfort and emotional support. Roughly 30 oxygen concentrators have been delivered to India from the U.S., and BAPS Charities is in the process of sending 150 more. “

(Featured Image Source: wikipedia.org)


Did you find this article useful? We’re a non-profit. Make a donation and help pay for our journalism.

HinduPost is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinions on issues concerning Hindu society, subscribe to HinduPost on Telegram.

close

Namaskar!

Sign up to receive HinduPost content in your inbox

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

About the Author

Anuradha
Writer, Editor, Researcher